Fish platter with prawns, crayfish, smoked salmon, mackerel, lemon mayonnaise, marie rose sauce and salad, at the 17th-century Black Horse Inn on Nuthurst Street in Nuthurst ,...
Seafood

Kelly's Fish House

Naples Bay • $$

Disclosure: Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. More info

A Taste of Old Florida

Kelly's Fish House has been serving fresh seafood on Naples Bay since 1953. It's a window into what Naples was before the high-rises and designer boutiques—a fishing village with fresh catch and Old Florida charm.

The History

Family-owned for generations, Kelly's maintains the traditions of classic Florida seafood dining. The view of Naples Bay, the pelicans, and the working waterfront haven't changed in decades.

The Seafood

Simple, fresh, and classic:

  • Fresh Fish: Whatever's running, simply prepared
  • Stone Crab Claws: In season, exceptionally fresh
  • Fried Shrimp: Gulf-caught, golden-fried
  • Whole Fried Fish: Old Florida tradition

The Experience

This isn't modern fine dining—it's wooden tables, checkered tablecloths, and no-fuss service. The charm is in its authenticity.

Tips

  • Cash only: They do not accept credit cards
  • Early dinner: Opens at 4pm, popular with locals
  • View tables: Get there early for bay-front seating
  • Casual dress: Come as you are

🍽️ Signature Dishes

  • Fresh Fish
  • Stone Crab
  • Fried Shrimp
  • Key Lime Pie

🏆 Awards & Recognition

  • Naples Institution Since 1953
Share:
Ask me anything about Naples!